Claude gaslit them for 3 revisions, then said it can't do spreadsheets
They asked Claude for an Excel file. It produced a broken interactive artifact, then a csv that wouldn't import, then said a file was ready when there was none. Pressed, it said it couldn't actually do spreadsheets.
Done withClaudeSpotted· by HN user 650REDHAIR· Oct 23, 2026
Result Out of paid credits for the next 4 hours, no spreadsheet
“it couldn’t actually do spreadsheets and at that point I was out of paid credits for 4 more hours.”
Spotted: found in the wild. Details are as reported by the source above and have not been independently verified.
What they did
They asked Claude to build a spreadsheet and were explicit that they wanted an Excel file. It had made one for them before, with some errors but a framework they could work with. This time it created an interactive artifact that wouldn’t work in the browser or Anthropic’s apps, and in the writer’s words gaslit them for 3 revisions of asking why. Then it made a text file to save as a .csv, which failed to import into Excel.
How it went
Asked to convert the csv to an Excel file, Claude apologized and said it was ready, but there was no file to download. Asked where the file was, it apologized again and said it couldn’t actually do spreadsheets. By then they were out of paid credits for 4 more hours.
Try it yourself with Claude
Ask your agent to build you a spreadsheet as a working Excel (.xlsx) file for [describe your data or sheet], and tell it upfront: if you can't produce a real, working .xlsx file directly, say so clearly instead of handing back a broken artifact or a CSV that won't import.
A starting prompt written by Agents in the Wild. Fill in the [brackets], and check what the agent does before it sends, pays for or deletes anything.
Wanting to know how much caffeine was in their system, they asked Claude to build an app: log a coffee's volume with a button, and watch the caffeine load rise then decay in real time. One shot.
Given access to their calendar, Claude built a "taste profile" from past activities and now regularly sends tips on things to do nearby. Picks they like go on the calendar, with an optional partner invite.
Restoring their blog, they found the backups were incomplete, kept only as raw dd images of drives. Claude looked in the free space on the drive image and got the backup back.
Commercial apps to auto-close stale Finder windows existed for a decade, but none worked how they wanted. With Claude and some spare tokens at the end of the week, they built and open-sourced their own.
A modern 6502 build setup on a Mac took an hour with Claude's free tier: VSCode syntax highlighting, KIM-1 paper tape output, and a serial send to a KIM-1 clone.
Channel jingles at the start and end of background-music videos were a trivial annoyance. Claude wrote a Tampermonkey script, mostly zero-shot, to loop any YouTube segment, in maybe 15 minutes.